
Well, I recently went ahead and watched this movie, and hoo boy was it long. At over 2 hours and 40 minutes, I believe it is the longest superhero movie ever made (unless you consider Orlanda Bloom as a superhero). I even fell asleep for an unknown period of time, and when I woke up, it was still boring.
Here's the bad -
1) For a $260 MILLION movie, the thing only has two and a half set-pieces. The first involving a plane which was not as engaging as I thought it's be, the second involving Superman lifting an entire fucking island. Now, I'm not sure about DC's laws of physics, but this second stunt was so unbelievably over the top that it makes you ponder why the hell was he having so much trouble againt Kaiser Soze and Kumar. I mean, the guy can take bullets to the freaking EYE, and he's not good enough to kill all the bad guys before they even blink? Fine, Supes doesn't kill people, but he could have knocked all their asses out and bring them in in under 3 seconds flat.
2) Child actors - I HATE them. The only child actors I have had
any form of respect for are Haley Joel Osment and Dakota Fanning. One taught me the virtues of paying it forward, while the other one looks legitimately creepy. Now, I don't know whether or not the kid here (forgot his name and his character's name) has any abilities mainly due to the fact that he has about 3 lines in the entire movie and are usually less than four or five syllables long. And for being Supes' son (c'mon people, if you haven't figured this out by the time you saw the trailer, you are a retard) he doesn't look like him at all. Plus, he has asthma, unkempt hair and has that "I'm so cute because I'm precocious" vibe that I violently hate. If my child were to be that way, I would bring out the belt.
3) The story itself is absolutely ridiculous. Lex Luther planning to destroy America by sinking it into the ocean to be replaced by Kryptonian land - a land that is 100% uninhabitable by humans - so that he could sell it as prime real estate? The Lex Luther would never, ever, be so idiotic. Just selling the rights to research those crystals to various militaries around the world would net in much more than fucking real estate. Lex wants to rule the world, not destroy it.
4) The special effects really are hit and miss. Sometimes it's apeshit crazy, other times Smallville, with the green screen effects very prominent. For a post-200 million dollar movie, how the hell did they not make sure everything looks perfect?
5) I want a fucking supervillain. Superman already went up against Luther, why make him do it again? At the end of the day, Superman made it out without a SCRATCH (aside from phoney melodrama). Give me Doomsday, give me Brainiac, give me Bizzaro, give me Darkseid. Hell give me Titano, the space monkey that can shoot Kryptonite from his eyes. But putting Superman up against a retarded Luther and his human cronies = FAILED.
6) The biggest peeve I have is why the hell does nobody notice that Superman and Clark were both away for exactly the same amount of time? The very day Clark returns to the office is the day of Supermans triumphent return to the public forum, and the supposedly brilliant, pulitzer winning journalist Louis Lane doesn't see a connection at all. It takes her fiance Cyclops to point out the weird coincidences (Return date, height, build, etc) for her to consider it and she flat outright rejects the notion. Only the kid notices, but he's resigned to look back and forth between Clark and pictures of Superman.
So, did I like anythings? You bet!
1) Brandon Routh is the only true successor to Reeves I can imagaine. He nails the role perfectly, from the voice to the mannerisms to his dominating physical presence. He's suitably heroic as Supes and perfectly dorky as Clark. This kid's a keeper.
2) Kevin Spacey, although playing a retarded rendition of Luther, manages to steal every scene he's in. He's just so damn good and being evil. Go Spacey.
3) The movie just feels right. The opening title sequence is a 5 minute orgasm of nostalgia with the blue text blurring by. The music is also perfect.
4) Marlon Brando, back from the dead! His archived dialogue as Jor-El gave me shivers.
5) Although the effects weren't even and there were too few action scenes, what's there will suffice for being the kick start of a new Superman series of films. Everything is competently done, and a few things (like the chaingun sequence) are pretty crazy.
Well, there you have it, my attempt at a film review. The movie was definitely good, but not the triumphic return the man of steel deserves. But, hell, it's Superman so just go watch it. Let them know the property is still profitable and maybe next time we'll really get to see Superman really die (against Doomsday).
7.4112903 out of 11.46682